Originally posted by alexbond45
View Post
We all draft players in the 7th round who have less chance of being good than 6% and yet we all still seem to think we'll hit the lottery.
The dice rolls giveth and taketh away.
Everything in this game is based around them, any chance of booming or busting is tied to them. Think of age as being a debuff to a player. Let's say a 7th year RB will have a -50% on their dice roll for age* and a -25% because of their position. Then factor in a -10% "fuck you" X factor to keep things random and you've got a pretty decent chance of that player tanking. Hell, the chance of staying relevant as a 7th year RB are probably worse than that.
*Note: I said a "7th year" and that might factor less than "29 year old". I can't recall if its true age or years in-game that matter more.
Now, I made those numbers up completely so don't expect to take them as something that's been tested, but the buff/debuff idea can be applied to anything. For instance, cohesion is a buff. My guess is that high cohesion on a unit is something like a +10% buff on dice rolls. An OC with amazing Playcalling will give the team a +5% on any given play. Good Strength Coordinators may give +10% boost to injury avoidance. Etc.
Like I said, your theory makes for a good story, but underneath everything is cold, hard coding and formulas. I don't think there's any evidence or indication that OL performance has any effect on bar ratings, the poor OL performance comes out in the stats of the RB. (Also true of other positions. As far as we know, the only thing GOOD performance does to the ratings is increases how quickly someone develops. I haven't seen evidence that bad performances do anything to a player, everything is derived from the bars.)
The way I think of Training Camp is that if I spend more time on Passing I'll get a +5% this season, while I get a -5% on the Running I stole time from. I don't think TC has any effect on whether or not a player booms or busts after Ex2 or TC, but are instead modifiers for the rest of the season in a more general sense. (Except for QB's and formations, that is directly effected by TC.)
Comment