2029 FA 2.3,4,5 SIM Complete - Next SIM Monday 05/20 = TC

[Sharkn20]

It seems all that TC info Ben published was dubious. I had thought this would happen but never got any data to back it up in my limited testing

I want to say that last season Andrews went 3 formationes losses... I think that he was getting older but also putted only one minute... But 3 hours in study play books will kill my time!! Damn it!! Thanks Rob!!

[Sharkn20]

What about weight up or down?? Is only useful when you want change main positions?? Or is reaaly important and affect ratings even if you don't change player's positions??

[mike17]

It seems all that TC info Ben published was dubious. I had thought this would happen but never got any data to back it up in my limited testing

I suspect this about a lot of info Ben has posted over the years. The best advice I can give is to take free advice with some healthy skepticism

[Guest]

I suspect this about a lot of info Ben has posted over the years.

QFT


Ive noted as well that if your qb has low intel he wont pick up formations quickly, or he seems to have a cap on how many he can learn.

When i Had Frodo (44 intel) he came into the league with 8 formations and in his 9th year hes only at 11
Monty Emmerson started with 8 formations (74 intel) and is up to 16 in his 10th year.

frodo played more but monty learned more

so at some point with a low intel QB film study seems to be a waste, ive not tested to see what that point is.

[Sharkn20]

Oh Chustz have 57 Intel.. Maybe could have 13 at the end of his career... Tomorrow will see...

[Guest]

Oh Chustz have 57 Intel.. Maybe could have 13 at the end of his career... Tomorrow will see...

not sure but i can say this after about 3 seasons of maxing film time 3 hrs frodo didnt pick up any more formations while monty would pick up 1 or 2 a season even after i reduced time to like 1 hour

[mike17]

not sure but i can say this after about 3 seasons of maxing film time 3 hrs frodo didnt pick up any more formations while monty would pick up 1 or 2 a season even after i reduced time to like 1 hour

I've been putting 1 min in film for 3 or 4 seasons and at least once Money gained a formation.

It's just a dice roll. You can get lucky or unlucky. The amount of time you put in loads the dice a bit, but it's not a guarantee for gain or loss.

[Guest]

I've been putting 1 min in film for 3 or 4 seasons and at least once Money gained a formation.

It's just a dice roll. You can get lucky or unlucky. The amount of time you put in loads the dice a bit, but it's not a guarantee for gain or loss.

Moneys intel is 74 so it seems like the intel could be the major factor.

[Guest]

Moneys intel is 74 so it seems like the intel could be the major factor.

Yes. The higher your QB's intelligence, the quicker he will learn formations (needing less film study than a QB with a lower intelligence).

[Guest]

Probably just a random % chance your QB learns or unlearns a formation which is modified by intelligence and film room time.

Unless you run a fuckton of simulated seasons it'll probably be hard to get solid data regarding it.

[mike17]

Probably just a random % chance your QB learns or unlearns a formation which is modified by intelligence and film room time.

Unless you run a fuckton of simulated seasons it'll probably be hard to get solid data regarding it.

Run TC -> Check formations -> Don't save -> repeat

[Aston]

I know someone ran a bunch (as in a handful, not a million) of those and seemed to think 1 minute film study was negligibly damaging, and you gained formations enough times any way.

I have been skeptical if there's anything more to film study than some [low either way] chance of gaining or losing formations but lately I'm throwing caution to the wind.

I think I either kept film study constant or increased it once in Green Bay and had my incoming starting QB lose a formation. So now I feel like why invest the time there.

[Guest]

I'm all for decimating film room time once a QB has a decent amount of them. Since I drafted a couple young backup caliber guys I've left it a little higher, but usually it's near zero for me.

[Sharkn20]

Well time to huddle and re-do TC stage. Thanks all. I still doubting in Weight importance, just a question of change positions?? Or affects player performance and ratings all over the field??

[Aston]

mike got to me in this thread, why change what's broken? We're taking those 30 minutes out of passing and putting them back into cohesion.

For specific player weight training, Shark, I imagine there's some penalty if the player isn't at perfect height/weight but I don't think it's significant. If a player can get closer I guess why not.

When you do want to change positions sometimes it's just necessary to drop weight first and move them after TC.

In TC, the training room time is for injuries, right?