1988 Draft Discussion

[Clay]

He was my #2 player overall.

See, maybe your board isn't as off of everyone else's as you first thought.

Or yours is as off as mine?????

My Scout has him with once in a lifetime type talent. 8-8-8-8-7 with 8-8-8 in the speed ratings and 7-6-7 at the OF positions. Obviously, I don't expect him to be that. But, even if he ends up at 5-5-5-5-5 with speed and defense, I'll take that.

[Jake]

I really liked Daly, but mainly because of those insane stats he's been putting up. My scout has him at 5-6-5-5-5, not spectacular for a first rounder, but I figured he'd be better than that. Really thought hard about taking him at 1.18, but I thought he might still be there in the 2nd. As usual, I was wrong. Nice pick.

[Lintyfresh85]

The Virginia Colonials are proud to welcome Morton West Mustang's Centerfielder Jerry Daly to the family. Daly was by far the #1 position player on our board and our Scouts love him. Jerry is the prototypical Colonial prospect with a great combination of blinding speed, power to the gaps and strong defense.

(Oh yeah... and we also love drafting guys named 'Jerry')

He was my #2 player overall.

See, maybe your board isn't as off of everyone else's as you first thought.

[Jistic]

Solid pick. Too bad he can't pitch.

[Clay]

The Virginia Colonials are proud to welcome Morton West Mustang's Centerfielder Jerry Daly to the family. Daly was by far the #1 position player on our board and our Scouts love him. Jerry is the prototypical Colonial prospect with a great combination of blinding speed, power to the gaps and strong defense.

(Oh yeah... and we also love drafting guys named 'Jerry')

[Spectre]

Done, sorry for the little delay

[Matt]

Mississippi is up...don't miss that pick!

[Carlos]

Your point is understood, but in the world of OOTP wouldn't you still have had a FB with a potential rating of 1? Obviousbly it was not a good pitch, but every pitcher knows how to throw one.

At least this discussion gave you a chance to relive your glory days.

It's by design.

There are pitchers that don't throw a true four-seam fastball so Markus coded the new pitching system to give a smaller percentage of guys only a cutter/sinker/two-seamer instead of the typical fastball.

I think the argument regarding the "1" rating for a fastball was: no pitcher would keep a pitch in his arsenal that simply did not work at all.

[Spectre]

Hey guys, I'll get my pick in before the end of the night for sure. I just got into my hotel and need to look through my draft list real quick. I'll probably reach a little bit, but we'll see.

[Jistic]

I'm very happy to land Scoley at #11. My scout had him as the 2nd best SP in the draft. Came down to him and Moran (Windy City's pick, who I now hate). Ratings are well developed and though the sample size is small he's been dominant thus far in his games.

Loved Scoley too. I didn't want a SP but if he was there and you took Moran I would've had to.

[Lintyfresh85]

The only guy my scout has hated so far in Moran. I must of copied down his ratings wrong as everyone else seems to love him.

[liquidcrash]

I'm very happy to land Scoley at #11. My scout had him as the 2nd best SP in the draft. Came down to him and Moran (Windy City's pick, who I now hate). Ratings are well developed and though the sample size is small he's been dominant thus far in his games.

[Lintyfresh85]

Very true.

[Andrew]

On the other hand... who knows how often pitcher develops new pitches. We haven't spent enough time with the game to see if stud prospects that look originially like relievers can turn into stud starters with the addition of that third pitch.

This would be pretty easy to test in single player. Draft a bunch of guys with 2 pitches who are listed as starters, lock them into the SP role and sim 5 years or so and see if they've developed more pitches.

[Lintyfresh85]

That's my biggest problem. How many pitches a guy throws shouldn't be an issue, it's how effective those pitches are. So is Cochran a reliever with two pitches or a starter with 7? Not to beat a dead horse, but without multiple scouts and with quite a few of the feeder league guys with no OSA report, it feels like another "broken" part of the scouting system.

In that case, I only trust my scout. He's an 80 overall for amateur scouting so I assume he knows what he's talking about.

On the other hand... who knows how often pitcher develops new pitches. We haven't spent enough time with the game to see if stud prospects that look originially like relievers can turn into stud starters with the addition of that third pitch.